Holistically assessing building performance

Kerry Shaw — Clean Energy Engineering Capstone Project

MEL Clean Energy Engineering student Kerry Shaw piloted a tool to help UBC identify if new buildings are living up to expectations.

UBC MEL in Clean Energy Engineering Capstone Project 2017 Kerry Shaw

As part of its 20-year sustainability strategy, UBC wants to see all residential and academic buildings on campus having a net positive impact on the environment and human well-being.

Achieving that ambitious goal will require a deeper understanding of how current buildings are performing — and that means developing better tools to assess a wide range of performance measures. To support this vision, UBC is developing a Green Building Plan for its Vancouver campus, which will govern sustainable development in all academic and residential buildings.

“One element being explored as part of UBC’s Green Building Plan is the use of post-occupancy evaluation studies to assess operating building performance and to inform the design of future projects,” explains Kerry Shaw, who was a student in the Master of Engineering Leadership (MEL) in Clean Energy Engineering program in 2017. “For my capstone project, I conducted a post-occupancy evaluation of UBC’s Alumni Centre as a pilot test to explore the logistics involved in completing such a study and to assess its usefulness as a tool.”

Post-occupancy evaluation (POE) studies are used to systematically and rigorously evaluate building performance and communicate project successes and failures. Typically, these studies combine energy and water consumption analysis with indoor environmental quality assessments to determine if actual performance is aligned with what was anticipated during the building’s design.

Kerry focused her study on the Robert H. Lee Alumni Centre. Completed in 2015, the Alumni Centre has attained gold-level LEED certification and includes social spaces, classrooms, high-tech meeting rooms and a café.

She reviewed two years of data and found that the actual energy use over the building’s operation was about 50 per cent higher than what was predicted. That difference is not surprising, she says, noting in her report that more than 50 per cent of LEED-certified buildings do not meet their energy and water use goals. Water consumption was significantly less than predicted – which led her to recommend that facilities staff confirm that all building water use is accurately being captured.

Kerry’s POE also incorporated other metrics beyond energy and water use, including a broad range of indoor environmental quality factors. She developed an online survey distributed to people who work in and use the building that asked them to reflect on 10 main topics, ranging from satisfaction with the social environment and building layout to thermal comfort and the building’s lighting and acoustics.

“These social environment elements are not typically included in POEs, but they are important for ensuring that UBC’s green building goals are met — including human well-being and placemaking,” she says.

The 41 people who responded to the survey were overall very satisfied with the building as a comfortable space to work and use.

“While the results of the POE in terms of energy and water metrics showed that the building isn’t performing the way it was predicted to, the occupant answers were overwhelmingly positive,” she says. “There is more going on in a building than how much energy it uses, and it is important to acknowledge the importance of how people feel in the space. People enjoy this building and being in it.”

Along with submitting a final report of her findings, Kerry presented the results of her POE study at a capstone conference, discussing both the results of this particular POE and its usefulness as a tool for better understanding a building’s environmental and social impacts. “My project mentors are interested in further exploring the use of POEs for future building projects on campus,” she says. “My project showed that POE is a viable tool for disseminating lessons learned from building projects, which will help inform the Green Building Plan’s development.”

Engineer standing by forested mountains and the ocean

Clean Energy Engineering

Develop the technical, business and leadership skills needed to generate sustainable energy solutions.

Clean Energy Engineering
UBC Crest The official logo of the University of British Columbia. Arrow An arrow indicating direction. Arrow in Circle An arrow indicating direction. Caret An arrowhead indicating direction. E-commerce Cart A shopping cart. Time A clock. Chats Two speech clouds. Facebook The logo for the Facebook social media service. Social Media The globe is the default icon for a social media platform. TikTok The logo for the TikTok social media platform. Calendar Location Home A house in silhouette. Information The letter 'i' in a circle. Instagram The logo for the Instagram social media service. Linkedin The logo for the LinkedIn social media service. Location Pin A map location pin. Mail An envelope. Telephone An antique telephone. Play A media play button. Search A magnifying glass. Arrow indicating share action A directional arrow. Speech Bubble A speech bubble. Star An outline of a star. Twitter The logo for the Twitter social media service. Urgent Message An exclamation mark in a speech bubble. User A silhouette of a person. Vimeo The logo for the Vimeo video sharing service. Youtube The logo for the YouTube video sharing service. Future of work A logo for the Future of Work category. Inclusive leadership A logo for the Inclusive leadership category. Planetary health A logo for the Planetary health category. Solutions for people A logo for the Solutions for people category. Thriving cities A logo for the Thriving cities category. University for future A logo for the University for future category.